Don’t Try to Hide Bad Acts Behind the Corporate (or LLC) Form of Doing Business
A Synopsis of Wasserman v. Kay, Court of Special Appeals of Maryland,
No. 2836, September Term, 2009, Filed February 9, 2011
Just because you are a member of a limited liability company (LLC) doesn’t mean that you are absolutely free of personal liability. This is especially so, in regard to your obligations to other members in the LLC.
Fiduciary Duties of Managing Members
In Maryland, no statute expressly addresses the fiduciary duties of LLC members. However, managing members of an LLC owe common law fiduciary duties to the LLC and to the other members of the LLC. As such, managing members are agents for the LLC and for each of the members, which is a fiduciary position under common law. Insurance Co. of North America v. Miller, 362 Md. 361 (2001).
Generally, no Maryland statute excludes or limits managing members’ fiduciary duties under common law. However, one Maryland statute governing LLC operating agreements does suggest that provisions within operating agreements could alter existing duties or create other duties that would not otherwise exist. Md Code, Corp. & Assoc. §4A-402(a).
Derivative Action against the LLC
Subtitle 8 of the Maryland Limited Liability Act (Md Code, Corp. & Assoc. §4A) in its entirety is devoted to derivative actions.
Section 4A-801(a) provides that “[a] member may bring a derivative action to enforce a right of a limited liability company to recover a judgment in its favor to the same extent that a stockholder may bring an action for a derivative suit under the corporation law of Maryland.”
Section 4A-801(b) provides that “[a]n action under this subtitle may be brought if members with authority to bring the action have refused to bring the action or if an effort to cause those members to bring the action is not likely to succeed.”
In many respects, the procedure for bringing a suit against a Maryland LLC mirrors the procedure for bringing a suit in a Maryland corporation—demand prerequisite/futility argument.
Direct Action by Member against another Member or the LLC
There is no express statute addressing the procedure for bringing direct actions by one member against another member or the LLC. So, we must turn to case law for guidance.
“In distinguishing individual or direct corporate actions from derivative actions, the court stated that, in contrast to a derivative action, a shareholder may bring a direct action against alleged corporate wrongdoers when either (1) the shareholder suffers the harm directly or (2) a duty is owed directly to the shareholder, though such harm may also be a violation of a duty owing to the corporation.” Wasserman v. Kay, quoting Shenker v. Laureate Education, Inc. at 345.
The Court of Special Appeals of Maryland extended this rationale in Wasserman v. Kay, No. 2836, September Term, 2009, Filed February 9, 2011 to the law of partnerships and LLCs. Therefore, a member can bring a direct action against another member or the LLC if (1) the member suffered the injury directly; and (2) the member violated duties (statutory or common law) owed directly to another member.
Members of an LLC are frequently parties to operating agreements. Thus, members are in contractual privity with each other. And, managing members of LLCs owe fiduciary duties to each other—not just the LLC itself.
Conclusion
The contractual, statutory, and fiduciary duties imposed on a managing member of an LLC may extend to both the LLC and the other members. Therefore, members must be aware that they cannot absolutely hide behind the LLC to release themselves of personal responsibility or individual liability.
Related articles:
For corporate director liability, business judgment, and derivative actions: Stockholder Derivative Claims: The Business Judgment Rule and Special Litigation Committees
For corporate demand requirements and demand futility: Stockholder Derivative Claims: Demand Futility
Work With BTLG, Attorneys at Law for All of Your Business Law Needs
BTLG was founded in 2000 to address the legal needs of businesses in the Baltimore region. Since our founding, we’ve helped over 1500 clients in the Mid-Atlantic across a wide array of industries. No matter what your business may need, our team of law experts can work with you to provide the best legal counsel and services. Contact us today by calling (410) 290-0707 or fill out our Contact form and we’ll reach out as soon as possible. And don’t forget to follow us on LinkedIn for more news and expert insights surrounding the world of business law.
