In an opinion published March 12, 2012, the United States District for Maryland in Arnold Weinberg derivatively and on behalf of BioMed Realty Trust Inc. v. Alan Gold, et al. reviewed and applied the legal standards set forth in Werbowsky v. Collomb, 362 Md. 581 (2001) to dismiss a stockholder derivative action. The impetus for the action was the board’s failure to rescind its approval of an executive compensation plan after a stockholder rejection (“say on pay”).The court dismissed the action on the corporate defendant’s motion to dismiss as the plaintiff had failed to make any demand of the board of directors under the principals articulated in Werbowsky. The court analyzed demand futility and found no basis to justify plaintiff’s failure to make demand, noting among other bases that there was business judgment applicable to the actions at issue.
In this decision, the District Court followed Werbowsky in requiring demand, with a narrow exception for futility: “We adhere, for the time being, to the futility exception, but, consistent with what appears to be the prevailing philosophy throughout the country, regard it as a very limited exception, to be applied only when the allegations or evidence clearly demonstrate, in a very particular manner, either that (1) a demand, or a delay in awaiting a response to a demand, would cause irreparable harm to the corporation, or (2) a majority of the directors are so personally and directly conflicted or committed to the decision in dispute that they cannot reasonably be expected to respond to a demand in good faith and within the ambit of the business judgment rule.” Decision p. 6 quoting Werbowsky at p. 144.
Related articles:
For director liability, business judgment, and derivative actions, see a related article: Stockholder Derivative Claims: The Business Judgment Rule and Special Litigation Committees
For liabilities due between members, see a related article: Hiding Behind the LLC-A Cautionary Tale on Member Disputes
Work With BTLG, Attorneys at Law for All of Your Business Law Needs
BTLG was founded in 2000 to address the legal needs of businesses in the Baltimore region. Since our founding, we’ve helped over 1500 clients in the Mid-Atlantic across a wide array of industries. No matter what your business may need, our team of law experts can work with you to provide the best legal counsel and services. Contact us today by calling (410) 290-0707 or fill out our Contact form and we’ll reach out as soon as possible. And don’t forget to follow us on LinkedIn for more news and expert insights surrounding the world of business law.
