Charging Orders for LLC Membership Interests

The Limited Liability Company (LLC) is an extremely attractive business entity offering members the benefit of limited liability from company debts, while also allowing the entity the benefit of a pass-through taxation structure commonly associated with partnerships.  A creditor of an LLC may attach to the LLC’s assets to satisfy a debt or claim, but a member’s personal assets can generally be insulated from reach.  (Under certain circumstances, though, a member can be held personally liable to the LLC’s creditors).  A creditor of an individual member may reach the member’s interest in the LLC to satisfy a purely personal debt.  This is typically achieved by way of a charging order.  

 A charging order is a judicial remedy that “charges” the interest of a member in an LLC with the payment of an unsatisfied judgment held against that member.  Until 2011, there was not much guidance to be found on this remedy in the Maryland statutes (Maryland Code, Corporations and Associations).   What was discernable from section 4A-607 of the statute was: 1) any creditor of a member could request a charging order against the judgment-debtor member’s membership interest for an unsatisfied judgment plus interest; 2) the judgment creditor was only given the rights of an assignee of the membership interest in the LLC; therefore, no control of the LLC or ability to participate in management was available to the judgment creditor; and 3) the member was not deprived of the benefit of any exemption laws applicable to the member’s interest.  When translated into actual practice, all this remedy actually meant was that a creditor had the ability to be granted a limited right to receive the distributions of a member directly from the LLC to be applied toward the member’s debt.  All too often, because the creditor has no say regarding if and when distributions will be made, the creditor was left without an adequate remedy.

As of June 1, 2011, a significant revision of the Maryland Limited Liability Company Act took effect. One of the sections that received substantial amending was the section on charging orders.  The newly amended section has now defined creditor and debtor, as applied to this specific section.  The definitions make it clear that any creditor can seek a charging order.  The revisions to the section also clarify that the charging order remedy can be sought, not only against a member of the LLC, but also against a person who is not a member but who holds an economic interest in the company.  Such a person would include a member’s assignee.   Further guidance has been added regarding how this specific remedy may be carried out. It is now expressly stated that the court may appoint a receiver to oversee the distributions from the LLC. 

What perhaps may be considered the most significant amendment to this section of the statute is that the court may now order foreclosure of the interest subject to the charging order.   The ability to foreclose on a member’s interest allows for a second method of recovery in those all too common situations where the right to receive a member’s distributions doesn’t actualize any real recovery.   The rights of the purchaser at the foreclosure sale are the rights provided to an assignee which under certain circumstances, as laid out in sections 4A-603 and 4A-604 of the Maryland Corporations and Associations Article, the purchaser may become a member of the LLC. In a situation of a single member LLC, the purchaser at foreclosure could become the sole member of the LLC.  Due to the fact that this new remedy could have drastic implications for the LLC, a section has been added to allow redemption of the member interest prior to foreclosure.   The interest may be redeemed through other property of the debtor, other property by one or more of the other members, or through property of the LLC with unanimous consent of all the members whose interests are not charged with payment of the judgment.  The final issue clarified by the 2011 amendment is that section 4A-607 is the exclusive remedy by which a creditor may attach to a member’s interest in an LLC.

While the 2011 amendments to the Maryland Limited Liability Act have substantially clarified and expanded the charging order remedy, on May 22, 2012, the Governor approved a bill containing 2012 amendments to the Maryland Limited Liability Act.  These amendments will take effect on October 1, 2012 and further expand the charging order statute. The first change to the statute provides clarification that the charging order lien is only against the member’s economic interest in the LLC.  Second, the changes require that before the court will consider foreclosure on the member’s interest, the creditor must present evidence that the distributions from the LLC will not satisfy the outstanding debt within a reasonable amount of time. Finally, the 2012 amendments change the language of the statute to clarify that the purchaser at foreclosure is an assignee, as opposed to a person who has the rights of an assignee, under section 4A-603 and 4A-604 of the statute.

Work With BTLG, Attorneys at Law for All of Your Business Law Needs

BTLG was founded in 2000 to address the legal needs of businesses in the Baltimore region. Since our founding, we’ve helped over 1500 clients in the Mid-Atlantic across a wide array of industries. No matter what your business may need, our team of law experts can work with you to provide the best legal counsel and services. Contact us today by calling (410) 290-0707 or fill out our Contact form and we’ll reach out as soon as possible. And don’t forget to follow us on LinkedIn for more news and expert insights surrounding the world of business law.