How Tax Filing Deficiencies Affect Your Business’ Ability to Judicially Enforce its Rights: A Specific Look at Corporations and Limited Liability Companies

Every April 15, Maryland law requires businesses [i] to file a personal property report with the Maryland State Department of Assessment and Taxation (“SDAT”). After the 30th of September each year, the State Comptroller certifies to the SDAT a list of every corporation and LLC that has failed to 1) pay taxes due, 2) pay unemployment insurance contributions and/or 3) failed to file an annual report with the SDAT as required by law. Corp. & Assoc. Art. §§ 3-503 and 4A-911.

Based upon these tax filing deficiencies, the SDAT will issue a proclamation declaring the charter of a corporation that has failed to file, “repealed, annulled and forfeited, and the powers conferred by law on the corporation [ ] inoperative, null and void.”  Corp. & Assoc. Art. §§ 3-503(d).  What this effectively means is that when a corporation’s charter is forfeited, the corporation is dissolved by operation of law and ceases to exist as a legal entity.  Kroop & Kurland, P.A. v. Lambros, 118 Md.App. 651 (1998).

As a legal non-entity, any act by a corporation while its charter is forfeit will be considered null and void. Tri-County Unlimited, Inc. v. Kids First Swim School Inc., 191 Md.App. 613 (2010).  This includes initiating a lawsuit against an individual or entity. A corporation cannot maintain an action to enforce its rights once it is considered a legal non-entity. Atlantic  Mill & Lumber Realty Co. v. Keefer, 179 MD 496 (1941).  

A corporation may reinstate its charter by fixing its tax filing deficiencies and then filing articles of revival with the SDAT. Corp. & Assoc. Art. §§ 3-507. Reinstatement of the corporate charter will restore all assets and rights back to the corporation, except for assets or rights that were sold or divested while the charter was forfeit. Corp. & Assoc. Art. §§ 3-512. Even though a corporation effectively becomes a legal entity again when its charter is reinstated, the reinstatement will not make valid a complaint that was filed during the time of the forfeited charter.  Tri-County Unlimited, 191 Md.App. at 621. A complaint filed during the time a corporation is a legal non-entity is considered to be a nullity as a matter of law and its filing will not toll the statute of limitations for the claim. Id at 622.

Unlike a corporation whose charter is appealed and annulled for tax filing deficiencies, an LLC who commits the same failures forfeits the right to do business in Maryland and the right to use the LLC name. Corp. & Assoc. Art. §4A-911(d). The LLC, however, is still considered to exist as a legal entity. Price et al. v. Upper Chesapeake Health Ventures, et al., 192 Md.App. 695 (2010).  

Maryland’s LLC statute states that an LLC whose rights to do business and to use its name are forfeited, may still defend an action in court.  Corp. & Assoc. Art. §4A-920.  The courts have interpreted the LLC statute to provide expressly for the defense of an action in court only.  This means that, like a corporation, a LLC cannot prosecute an action in court while its rights have been forfeited. Price, 192 Md.App. at  709. The court’s interpretation of the statute is further bolstered by the fact that a forfeited LLC is no longer able to use the LLC name and therefore cannot initiate suit using the LLC name.  MD Rule 2-201 requires every action shall be prosecuted in the name of a real party in interest.  Forfeited LLC’s cannot satisfy this requirement.  Price, 192 Md.App at 712.

Whether you are a corporation or a LLC, it is important to pay close attention to your tax filing obligations as required by the state. Failure to do so will result in your business’ inability to use the court system to enforce its legal rights and can subject your claims to expiration under the statute of limitations if you do not fix your deficiencies before the limitation period terms.  


[i] Businesses as used in this article refers to: business trusts; statutory trusts; domestic corporations, limited liability companies, limited liability partnerships, limited partnerships; and foreign corporations, statutory trusts; limited liability companies, limited liability partnerships, limited partnerships registered or qualified to do business in the State of Maryland. Md. Code Ann., Tax-Property, §11-101.

Work With BTLG, Attorneys at Law for All of Your Business Law Needs

BTLG was founded in 2000 to address the legal needs of businesses in the Baltimore region. Since our founding, we’ve helped over 1500 clients in the Mid-Atlantic across a wide array of industries. No matter what your business may need, our team of law experts can work with you to provide the best legal counsel and services. Contact us today by calling (410) 290-0707 or fill out our Contact form and we’ll reach out as soon as possible. And don’t forget to follow us on LinkedIn for more news and expert insights surrounding the world of business law.